Compare

Compared with the tools you’re weighing

Each of these does part of the job well. The tables show how much each one runs, who sets its limits and what it records about each change.

Join the beta Try the live demo

One situation, two ways

Click prices rise 10% in six weeks

A coffee roaster’s cost per click on brewing gear rose 10 percent over six weeks as big retailers started their holiday bidding.

Platform AI

Each platform’s AI keeps bidding toward its own target in its own campaigns. It may pay the higher price or move to cheaper placements, and you see the outcome in its summary report.

Heraldic

The New Customers agent reported the rise, asked the creative desk for new brew-along ads and, once you approved them, proposed launching them: $40 a day for 14 days, $560 in all. Launches wait for your approval by default, and your spend caps hold either way.

The same questions, asked of each

How Heraldic compares with Shopify Campaign Autopilot, Klaviyo Composer, HubSpot’s marketing agents, Madgicx
Question	Shopify Campaign Autopilot	Klaviyo Composer	HubSpot’s marketing agents	Madgicx	Heraldic
What it runs	Meta, Microsoft and Snapchat ads, Shop Campaigns, Shopify email and product SEO, for Shopify stores	Email, SMS and push in Klaviyo; on ads, Meta results in Composer and audiences synced to four ad platforms	Campaign plans, content and nurture email in HubSpot; none of its listed agents runs paid ads	Meta ads only; its reports read other channels	Paid ads and lifecycle email, with an agent for each job
Who acts	Autopilot launches and funds ads on its own or after your approval; you approve every email tactic	Composer drafts and audits; you approve every send and every flow	Its marketing agents plan and draft for you to publish; the nurture agent personalizes sends once on	AI Marketer acts on its own or after your approval; rules you set run around the clock	Agents propose; for each kind of action, you choose whether it waits for you
Your limits	A monthly budget target it can overshoot (Shopify credits the difference on request), plus targets for return on ad spend, regions and languages	Your brand, voice and compliance guidance on every draft, and a person approves every send	Set email by email for the nurture agent: locked text, data sources, share of recipients, credit cap	Approval mode, if you choose it, and automated rules	Daily spend caps, a 20% limit on each change, and contact and content rules, checked before every change; no raise once the month’s cap is reached
Judged on	Reach, sessions, orders and sales for each tactic	Conversions Klaviyo credits to its messages (last touch, by default)	Attributed revenue, ROI and deal influence in your CRM	Your Meta ad data, made more complete by its tracking	Your conversion events, each valued by what it’s worth to you
The record	A timeline of actions for each tactic	Citations and its reasoning as it works; Klaviyo’s activity log records changes	Previews show why it changed the text; sent versions viewable for 30 days	Latest changes to each ad set, and details for each recommendation	Every action, with who proposed it, why, the checks it passed and who approved it
Creative	Ads from your catalog images; it writes and styles its own emails	Drafts emails, SMS, flows and segments	Drafts content, emails and ad copy	Generates image ads	Images and copy drafted from your approved library; none runs until it’s approved
What it costs	Free on paid Shopify plans except Agentic; the ad platforms bill ad spend, and Shopify bills Shop Campaigns and email sends.	Usage-based: every account gets $5 of Composer use a month free; a $20 monthly plan includes four times that.	HubSpot Credits, $10 per 1,000; Marketing Studio needs Marketing Hub Pro or Enterprise.	A single plan, priced by ad spend, from $45 a month; its tracking add-on is $49 a month; 7-day free trial.	Not set yet. Ad spend goes straight to the ad platforms

What it runs

Heraldic: Paid ads and lifecycle email, with an agent for each job

Shopify: Meta, Microsoft and Snapchat ads, Shop Campaigns, Shopify email and product SEO, for Shopify stores
Klaviyo: Email, SMS and push in Klaviyo; on ads, Meta results in Composer and audiences synced to four ad platforms
HubSpot: Campaign plans, content and nurture email in HubSpot; none of its listed agents runs paid ads
Madgicx: Meta ads only; its reports read other channels

Who acts

Heraldic: Agents propose; for each kind of action, you choose whether it waits for you

Shopify: Autopilot launches and funds ads on its own or after your approval; you approve every email tactic
Klaviyo: Composer drafts and audits; you approve every send and every flow
HubSpot: Its marketing agents plan and draft for you to publish; the nurture agent personalizes sends once on
Madgicx: AI Marketer acts on its own or after your approval; rules you set run around the clock

Your limits

Heraldic: Daily spend caps, a 20% limit on each change, and contact and content rules, checked before every change; no raise once the month’s cap is reached

Shopify: A monthly budget target it can overshoot (Shopify credits the difference on request), plus targets for return on ad spend, regions and languages
Klaviyo: Your brand, voice and compliance guidance on every draft, and a person approves every send
HubSpot: Set email by email for the nurture agent: locked text, data sources, share of recipients, credit cap
Madgicx: Approval mode, if you choose it, and automated rules

Judged on

Heraldic: Your conversion events, each valued by what it’s worth to you

Shopify: Reach, sessions, orders and sales for each tactic
Klaviyo: Conversions Klaviyo credits to its messages (last touch, by default)
HubSpot: Attributed revenue, ROI and deal influence in your CRM
Madgicx: Your Meta ad data, made more complete by its tracking

The record

Heraldic: Every action, with who proposed it, why, the checks it passed and who approved it

Shopify: A timeline of actions for each tactic
Klaviyo: Citations and its reasoning as it works; Klaviyo’s activity log records changes
HubSpot: Previews show why it changed the text; sent versions viewable for 30 days
Madgicx: Latest changes to each ad set, and details for each recommendation

Creative

Heraldic: Images and copy drafted from your approved library; none runs until it’s approved

Shopify: Ads from your catalog images; it writes and styles its own emails
Klaviyo: Drafts emails, SMS, flows and segments
HubSpot: Drafts content, emails and ad copy
Madgicx: Generates image ads

What it costs

Heraldic: Not set yet. Ad spend goes straight to the ad platforms

Shopify: Free on paid Shopify plans except Agentic; the ad platforms bill ad spend, and Shopify bills Shop Campaigns and email sends.
Klaviyo: Usage-based: every account gets $5 of Composer use a month free; a $20 monthly plan includes four times that.
HubSpot: HubSpot Credits, $10 per 1,000; Marketing Studio needs Marketing Hub Pro or Enterprise.
Madgicx: A single plan, priced by ad spend, from $45 a month; its tracking add-on is $49 a month; 7-day free trial.

From each product’s own pages, checked November 1, 2026. Each comparison lists its sources.

Where each one is strong, and where it stops

Running it without another product

Check the arithmetic yourself.

Your work email is all we need to start.

Or try the live demo first